Death of the Mentor: Must we Part?

Everybody loves a good mentor. From Obi-Wan Kenobi to Haymitch Abernathy, the wizened master who must pass on their knowledge holds a special place in our hearts. However there comes a time when the hero must learn to stand on their own two feet. This often manifests itself in the death of the mentor trope. A sad bench mark in the monomyth of the hero's journey that raises the stakes while forcing the hero to grow.
Same as any character death, the mentor's death has to mean something to the plot and/or the characters. If the mentor dies ‘for nothing’ it makes the audience feel cheated and can feel like a forced attempt to infuse emotion into the story.
Example: When Gandalf the Grey is killed in The Lord of the Rings. Even though he comes back as Gandalf the White later on, his absence leads to two things; it forces Aragon to become a leader and influences Frodo's choice to trust Gollum. Aragon's character arc is one where he must face the destiny he has spent most of his adult life running from, becoming the king of Gondor. After Gandalf dies, he must lead the fellowship of the ring to Mordor, which includes protecting Gondor and its nearby kingdoms. It also softens Frodo's view of Gollum leading to his decision to trust him as a guide because Gandalf mentioned he might have a part to play in their quest.
What can make the death of a mentor unique compared to the death of a sidekick or love interest, is that it solidifies the feeling that it’s up to the hero to save the day. The loss of the support of someone older and wiser should make the hero feel lost. They must now be the one to use the knowledge given to them to protect those they love without the comfort of a guiding hand.
Example: When Yoda dies in Star Wars: Return of the Jedi there is a shift in the movie's stakes. As far as we know he is now the last Jedi who must destroy the emperor, survive, and pass on his knowledge. He is briefly consoled by the ghost of his other mentor Obi Wan Kenobi who offers closure, reveals the identity of his sister, and confirms that he must fight his own father. This is what makes the audience invested in the movie's ending, as the fate of the galaxy and the Jedi way truly lies in the hands of Skywalker and the other rebels.
But must it always be this way? If killing the mentor feels a little too extreme or might feel forced in the story you have in mind there are always alternatives. It is best not to try to fit a square peg into a round hole, so you should consider the other way the hero could lose their mentor in a way that might be even more impactful.
Example: In Spiderman: Homecoming Tony Stark (who I know dies later in the franchise but bare with me) takes away the suit he has made Peter Parker because he fears Peter is taking too many risks. Even though he doesn’t die (yet) Peter still loses Tony as a mentor which devastates him and makes him contemplate why he became Spiderman in the first place. He tries to go back to his old life as a regular teenager who wants to take his crush to homecoming and ends up distracted at the realization he must stop the Vulture. He finds his old homemade suit and faces Vulture with nothing but his powers and natural intuition without all the technology Tony gave him.
At the end of the day, no one wants to see the mentor go but it is sometimes necessary for the hero to put all the lessons they have learned to the test. This shows true growth and can lead to a satisfying ending. Though there are many ways to go about how this happens, it is best to single out the when, where, who, and how that will lead to the most emotional payoff for the characters and the plot.
About the author:
Naomi is a rising junior at UW Seattle majoring in English: Creative Writing. She has had a short story published in student journal Bricolage in 2023. She now hopes to go into publishing as an editor or first reader while writing for children and young adults. This is her first time working with Writers Workout and is thankful for the opportunity.
.png)



Comments