top of page

What's My Motivation?

7 hours ago
5 min read
What's My Motivation text across hands holding a heart (symbolizing wants).

Crafting Characters With Nuanced Desires


What makes a character in a book feel real? So real that you carry them around in your heart for years to come? So relatable that you start to identify with them? That you feel seen by them? Some people may think it’s the character’s personality, their sass or integrity or incomparable wit. Or maybe it’s their perseverance, the way they overcome every obstacle, no matter the odds. What a lot of people don’t realize is that what most attracts us to a character isn’t actually their flaws or attributes, but what they want. We love characters with the same wants and fears as us. 


Now you may be thinking, but my favorite character’s ultimate want is to save the world from space pirates—that’s nothing like me! 


On the surface, many of the characters that speak to us appear to have very different wants and fears from us, but what’s incredible is that most people—and most characters—actually all want the same thing. They just don’t know it. 


This is a little known secret I learned in drama school, which involved a fair bit more psychology than people might think. All of this psychoanalysis is called character work, and it’s how actors manage to take a character with only 45 minutes of dialogue about solving a mathematical theorem and turn them into someone you see yourself in. So let's dive in.



Character Work 101: What Do They Want?


Every person, and so every character, wants a lot of different things at once. We want to get home without running into traffic, and we want the date tomorrow to go well, and we want to pay our bills. These separate wants can all exist at the same time, and they’re called immediate wants. They have to do with the here and now and will usually be accomplished or not within the next few minutes to days. In every scene, your character will have a different immediate want. In the first scene, they may want to get home on time, and then suddenly they want to escape a robber. In the next scene, they want to track down their stolen heirloom necklace. Your characters will accomplish or fail to accomplish many different immediate wants throughout your story. 


But beneath all these little, transitory wants is the Big Want. The throughline of your story. This is the goal your character is aiming for throughout the entire plot—the one they likely won’t accomplish until just before or at the end. This Big Want is like the river current that carries your entire story, ferrying your character to their ultimate fate. 


So let's say your character’s whole aim throughout the book is to get that big promotion and become the boss. Cut and dry right? That’s their Big Want.


Actually, no. In all likelihood, what this character wants most of all goes deeper than a promotion, and you, the author, knowing just how deep is what’s going to make the character feel important to readers, regardless of whether they’ve ever aspired to corporate success. 



What They Think They Want


People, and subsequently characters, often think they know what their greatest goal in life is. It’s usually a fairly straightforward, attainable goal, with reasonably clear steps to get there. We want to make money. To make good art. To do the right thing. To get married, etc. The thing is, these straightforward, conceivably attainable wants are usually just derivatives of more essential, more archetypal desires. 


One way to think about this is through Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. Down at the bottom, the most basic level of the hierarchy, are things we need to survive: food, water, shelter. This is Tom Hanks’ character in Castaway. His biggest want is survival. Every small or large goal he has is ultimately in service of this want. 


If your character has everything they need to meet their biological needs, they move on to safety. This is Katniss Everdeen. What she wants most is safety for her friends, family, and people, and this motivates everything she does throughout the series. 


If your character isn’t fearing for their life on a daily basis, they go up a rung to love and belonging. This is where most people, and thus most characters, hover. The problem is, it’s easy to recognize “I need food and shelter” or “I need to be safe from people chasing me” because these have fairly cut and dry steps to follow: get food, build a shelter, run. But how do we get love and belonging? 


Very few people think “what I want most is love and belonging” because it’s existential; it feels big and scary and amorphous and there’s no surefire way to guarantee it or to know for sure we truly have it or can keep it. You can’t shoot it out of the sky or harvest it from the ground. The people we love could leave or get bored of us. So we convince ourselves that actually, what we want most are these smaller, more (in our minds) straightforward wants—getting the promotion, becoming a famous artist—because deep down, we believe that achieving these things will help us get or keep the love and belonging we desire. 


There are steps to this, of course. The promotion does not automatically equal love and belonging. But we can trace the character’s subconscious steps to get there:

  • If I get that promotion I will be seen as good at my job and I will be admired. 

  • I will be seen as a good provider, and my family will appreciate me and want to keep me around. They’ll be grateful for me.

  • My parents will be proud. 

  • I will prove my worth as a person. 


All of this together ultimately serves the goal of obtaining love and belonging. 


Most characters don’t have the self-awareness to see the love and belonging gears turning beneath their more immediate wants (and this is usually a good thing; very self-aware characters tend to make less mistakes, which means less plot for you to play with), so they go all in on the goal they’ve subconsciously decided will get them there. 


This usually works the same for fears as well. Characters may think their biggest fear is failure, but really they’re afraid of the rejection that failure could bring: the loss of love and belonging.  



How Relatable


When you start viewing characters through this lens, you realize you have a lot more in common with them than you previously thought. A character that once was preoccupied with defeating space pirates suddenly crystallizes into someone who desperately needs to prove they’re worthy of the love they so crave. And who can’t relate to that? 


So when you’re crafting your next character, think like an actor and ask, What do they want, and then when you think you have the answer, ask why they want that. Then why they want that. All the way down until you land on something universal. Something everyone wants.


When you understand your character's psychology on this level, it will bleed through in your writing, even if you never specifically talk about it. This Big Want will show up subtextually in their interactions with other characters, in their internal monologue, how they respond to obstacles, and in what they fear. Readers will be able to feel this deeply human truth hidden beneath everything the character does, and they will identify with it. They will love it.




About the author: Alexandra is a neurodivergent writer and performer from the southern Appalachians. Her work has appeared or is forthcoming in Mid-American Review, DreamForge, Flash Fiction Magazine, and more. When she's not writing, she's researching for her next project and trying (unsuccessfully) to convince her little black cat to cuddle with her.   


Comments


bottom of page